August 24, 2007 Caitlin Upton takes Miss Teen USA’s Top 5 with Sherri Hill Miss South Carolina Caitlin Upton, also 3rd Runner-Up for Miss Teen USA 2007, graced the stage, as well as recent YouTube videos, last August wearing a classic baby blue Sherri Hill evening gown. Hill’s quality and intricate design allowed Caitlin to dazzle the audience and other U.S. Americans with her beauty.